automation

Why Video-First Monetization Strategies Are Publishers' Last Line of Defense Against AI-Powered Traffic Collapse

As AI search decimates web traffic, publishers pivoting to video-first monetization can protect revenues, command premium CPMs, and build AI-resistant businesses.

Why Video-First Monetization Strategies Are Publishers' Last Line of Defense Against AI-Powered Traffic Collapse

The Existential Crisis Facing Digital Publishers

There is no gentle way to frame what is happening to digital publishing. The traffic model that has sustained digital media for two decades is collapsing in real time. Google's AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and a growing constellation of AI-powered search alternatives are systematically dismantling the referral traffic pipeline that publishers have relied upon since the early days of the web. The numbers are stark. According to a Digital Content Next survey of 19 major publishers conducted between May and June 2025, organic search referral traffic from Google declined by a median of 10% year-over-year, with non-news brands experiencing an even steeper 14% decline :cite[g8q]. Some publishers report click-through rate drops of up to 89% on queries where AI Overviews appear :cite[ch7]. The Guardian reported that sites previously ranked first in search results can lose up to 79% of traffic when pushed below an AI Overview :cite[sil]. This is not a temporary fluctuation. This is a structural shift in how information is discovered, consumed, and monetized online. For publishers who have built their businesses on search-driven display advertising, affiliate revenue, and programmatic display, the implications are severe. If users never arrive at your site, they never see your ads, never click your affiliate links, and never subscribe to your newsletter. The entire revenue architecture crumbles. Yet within this crisis lies an opportunity. Video, and particularly connected television (CTV), represents perhaps the last defensible position for publishers seeking sustainable monetization in an AI-disrupted landscape. This is not simply about following the money to where advertisers are spending. It is about building content moats that AI cannot easily abstract, commoditize, or summarize away.

Why Text-Based Content Is Uniquely Vulnerable

To understand why video represents a defensive position, we must first understand why text-based content is so vulnerable to AI disruption. Text is the native language of large language models. Every article, blog post, and web page you publish feeds directly into the training data and retrieval systems that power AI Overviews and chatbots. Your carefully crafted explainer on "how to remove red wine stains" can be summarized in three sentences by an AI, served directly in search results, and your traffic reduced to zero. The Professional Publishers Association submitted evidence to the UK's Competition and Markets Authority documenting this pattern in detail. One lifestyle publisher member tracked a popular search query about pest control and found that despite maintaining a first-page ranking and stable impressions, their click-through rate collapsed from 5.1% to 0.6% over a single year :cite[g8q]. The content remained discoverable. The traffic simply evaporated. This is the zero-click apocalypse in action. Zero-click searches now account for nearly 60% of Google's mobile queries, and AI Overviews appear for roughly 30% of processed searches :cite[ch7]. For informational publishers, whose content is most easily summarized, the exposure is existential. The response from some publishers has been to erect paywalls, limiting what AI systems can scrape and forcing users to pay for access. But this creates its own problems. As Search Engine Land noted, "If users get answers without ever reaching a publisher's site, they never hit the paywall and never become subscribers" :cite[ch7]. You cannot convert users who never arrive. Others have pursued licensing deals with AI companies, but as Nieman Lab reported in late 2025, "Publishers will see no meaningful AI licensing revenue" :cite[bs0]. The economics simply do not work at scale for most publishers. Video, however, operates under fundamentally different dynamics.

The Structural Advantages of Video Content

Video content is not immune to AI, but it possesses structural characteristics that make it far more defensible than text:

  • Temporal complexity: Video is not a static document. It unfolds over time, with narrative arcs, emotional beats, visual sequences, and audio layers that cannot be meaningfully summarized in a text snippet. An AI Overview can tell you the ingredients for a recipe; it cannot replicate the experience of watching a chef demonstrate technique, explain common mistakes, and reveal the sensory cues that indicate doneness.
  • Production barriers: Quality video requires cameras, lighting, talent, editing, and distribution infrastructure. These barriers to entry mean that video content is not as easily commoditized as text, which can be generated at near-zero marginal cost by AI systems.
  • Platform control: Video lives on platforms where publishers maintain more control over the user experience. Whether that is a streaming app, a CTV channel, or an embedded player on a website, video creates contained environments where advertising can be integrated without depending on search referral traffic.
  • Attention economics: Video commands attention in ways that text cannot. The average video ad completion rate far exceeds the engagement rates of display advertising. Users do not "skip" a pre-roll ad in the same way they ignore a banner. This attention premium translates directly into CPM premiums.
  • First-party data generation: Video platforms, particularly those requiring login, generate rich first-party data about viewing behavior, preferences, and engagement patterns. This data becomes increasingly valuable as third-party cookies deprecate and privacy regulations tighten.

As AdExchanger reported, "Video is where attention lives, yet most 'AI for video' still treats it like a pile of screenshots and a transcript. That misses what matters in motion pictures: sequence, sound and telling a story over time" :cite[ad7]. This gap between what AI can process and what video actually contains is precisely what makes video defensible.

The CTV Opportunity: Numbers That Matter

The connected television market is not merely growing. It is becoming the dominant mode of video consumption and, increasingly, of all video advertising. According to the IAB's 2025 Digital Video Ad Spend & Strategy Report, total U.S. digital video ad spend grew 18% year-over-year in 2024 to $64 billion and was projected to reach $72 billion in 2025, increasing two to three times faster than total media :cite[d29]. eMarketer estimates that streaming-service CPMs average around $26 to $27, a significant premium over display advertising :cite[cxc]. The FreeWheel Video Marketplace Report for the first half of 2025 revealed that streaming platforms saw ad view growth of 27% year-over-year across the US and Europe combined :cite[cvs]. In the United States, 85% of streaming ad views now occur on CTV devices. Programmatic ad views grew 29% year-over-year in the US and 44% in Europe, with programmatic now representing 30% of all premium video ad delivery in the US :cite[cvs]. These are not marginal improvements. This is a fundamental shift in where advertising dollars flow. Roku predicts that by 2026, up to 50% of streaming advertisers will subsidize CTV ad spend increases with budgets siphoned from search and social :cite[aqh]. Think about what that means: advertisers are actively moving money away from the channels most disrupted by AI and toward video environments where their messages can still command attention. For publishers, the strategic implication is clear. The runway for text-based, search-dependent monetization is shortening. The opportunity in video is expanding. The question is not whether to pivot, but how quickly and how comprehensively.

Building a Video-First Revenue Architecture

Transitioning to video-first monetization is not a simple matter of adding a video player to your existing pages. It requires rethinking content strategy, technology infrastructure, and revenue operations from the ground up.

Content Strategy Transformation

The most fundamental shift is moving from text-first to video-first content planning. This does not mean abandoning text entirely, but rather:

  • Lead with video: For any piece of content where visual demonstration adds value, the video should be the primary asset, with text serving as supporting material for SEO and accessibility.
  • Build for platforms, not just web: Content should be conceived for distribution across YouTube, TikTok, streaming platforms, and CTV channels, not merely embedded on a website hoping for search traffic.
  • Invest in original formats: AI can summarize generic content. It cannot replicate unique personalities, proprietary access, or distinctive production styles. Publishers must invest in formats that are defensibly differentiated.
  • Think in series, not articles: Video rewards serialization and subscriber relationships. A cooking show builds audience loyalty across episodes in ways that discrete recipe posts cannot.

Technology and Infrastructure

Video-first publishing requires significantly different technology infrastructure:

  • Video hosting and delivery: Enterprise-grade video platforms that can handle encoding, adaptive bitrate streaming, and global CDN distribution.
  • Ad serving integration: Server-side ad insertion (SSAI) for CTV environments, video header bidding for programmatic demand, and direct sales tools for premium inventory.
  • Measurement and analytics: Video-specific analytics that track completion rates, engagement patterns, and cross-platform viewing behavior.
  • CTV app development: For publishers pursuing direct CTV distribution, native apps for Roku, Fire TV, Apple TV, and other platforms are essential.

Revenue Operations

The monetization model for video differs substantially from display advertising:

  • Higher CPMs, lower volume: Video commands premium rates but serves fewer impressions per session than display. Revenue optimization focuses on completion rates and viewability rather than raw impression volume.
  • Programmatic and direct sales hybrid: Premium video inventory often sells through a combination of programmatic guaranteed deals and direct sales relationships. Publishers need both capabilities.
  • Subscription integration: Many successful video publishers operate hybrid models with ad-supported free tiers and premium subscription options. This diversification reduces dependence on any single revenue stream.
  • Sponsorship and branded content: Video creates opportunities for deeper brand integrations, including sponsored series, product placements, and custom content partnerships that command significant premiums over standard advertising.

The FAST Channel Opportunity

Free Ad-Supported Streaming Television (FAST) channels represent a particularly compelling opportunity for publishers with existing video libraries or the capacity to produce original content. FAST channels operate like traditional linear television, with scheduled programming and commercial breaks, but are delivered over streaming platforms like Pluto TV, Tubi, Samsung TV Plus, and others. For publishers, FAST offers:

  • Immediate CTV distribution: Rather than building your own CTV apps, you can launch a FAST channel on platforms with existing audiences of millions.
  • Lean-back viewing environment: FAST viewers behave more like traditional TV viewers, watching for extended periods with higher ad tolerance than on-demand streaming.
  • Programmatic monetization: FAST platforms handle ad sales, allowing publishers to monetize without building their own sales infrastructure.
  • Library leverage: Publishers with existing video archives can repurpose content into themed channels without significant new production investment.

The FreeWheel data shows that in the US, 56% of premium video ad views occur in live environments, driven by live sports and FAST channels :cite[cvs]. In the UK, FAST is "rapidly growing as audiences increasingly enjoy the familiar, 'live' experience of linear TV through digital devices" :cite[cvs]. For publishers who have accumulated video content over years of production, FAST represents a monetization opportunity for assets that may be underutilized on their owned properties.

Live Video: The Ultimate Moat

If video is defensible against AI disruption, live video is a fortress. Live content cannot be pre-summarized. It cannot be scraped and served as an AI Overview. It creates appointment viewing that builds habit and loyalty. And it commands premium advertising rates that dwarf both display and on-demand video. Google's Ad Manager team published research emphasizing that "the future of live event monetization is programmatic. Publishers who adopt a hybrid monetization strategy and demand high-performance infrastructure are better positioned to capture the growing value of live streaming" :cite[dba]. Live programming encompasses more than just sports, though sports remain the highest-value live content category:

  • News and current events: Breaking news coverage, election coverage, and real-time market analysis.
  • Events and conferences: Industry events, award shows, and product launches.
  • Interactive content: Q&A sessions, live shopping, and interactive entertainment.
  • Creator-driven programming: Live streams from personalities and influencers with engaged audiences.

With major live events on the 2026 calendar, including the men's football World Cup, the Winter Olympics, and the Super Bowl, publishers with live video capabilities are positioned to capture significant advertising spend.

First-Party Data: Video's Hidden Advantage

Beyond the direct monetization benefits, video-first strategies generate first-party data assets that become increasingly valuable as privacy regulations tighten and third-party cookies disappear. When a user watches video on your platform, you learn:

  • Content preferences: What topics, formats, and creators they engage with.
  • Engagement patterns: How long they watch, when they drop off, and what drives completion.
  • Cross-session behavior: Viewing history that reveals interests and intent over time.
  • Device and context: Where and when they watch, enabling contextual targeting.

This data enables both better content decisions and more valuable advertising products. Publishers can build audience segments based on demonstrated interests, offer advertisers targeting capabilities that do not depend on third-party cookies, and personalize experiences that drive loyalty and retention. As Omeda's research on first-party data transformation noted, "First-party data helps build direct relationships with audiences, improve content personalization, and open up new avenues for monetization" :cite[dk9]. Video platforms are natural engines for generating this data at scale.

Strategic Implementation: A Phased Approach

For publishers currently dependent on text-based, search-driven monetization, the transition to video-first requires a phased approach that balances immediate revenue needs with long-term strategic positioning.

Phase 1: Assessment and Foundation (0-6 Months)

  • Audit existing video assets: Many publishers have more video content than they realize, accumulated across years of sporadic production. Catalog what you have and assess its potential for repackaging.
  • Evaluate production capabilities: Determine what video content you can produce with existing resources and what would require new investment.
  • Technology assessment: Evaluate your current video hosting, ad serving, and analytics capabilities against requirements for video-first monetization.
  • Revenue modeling: Build financial models comparing your current text-based revenue trajectory against video investment scenarios.

Phase 2: Pilot and Learn (6-18 Months)

  • Launch pilot video series: Start with formats that leverage existing expertise and audience relationships. Learn what works before scaling.
  • Test monetization models: Experiment with different ad formats, placements, and pricing to understand your video inventory's value.
  • Build operational capabilities: Develop workflows for video production, editing, distribution, and monetization that can scale.
  • Explore platform partnerships: Test distribution on YouTube, social platforms, and potentially FAST channels to understand where your content finds audience.

Phase 3: Scale and Diversify (18-36 Months)

  • Scale successful formats: Double down on video content and formats that demonstrate strong engagement and monetization.
  • Build CTV presence: Launch dedicated CTV apps or FAST channels to capture the growing streaming audience.
  • Develop premium offerings: Create sponsorship packages, branded content capabilities, and premium subscription tiers.
  • Integrate across business: Ensure video strategy aligns with and supports broader business objectives, from audience development to advertiser relationships.

The SSP Perspective: Supporting Publisher Transformation

For SSPs and ad tech platforms serving the supply side, publisher video transformation represents both an opportunity and an imperative. Publishers who successfully pivot to video-first strategies will need:

  • Video-specific inventory management: Tools that handle the complexity of video ad formats, placements, and serving requirements.
  • CTV monetization capabilities: Server-side ad insertion, CTV device support, and programmatic infrastructure for streaming environments.
  • Advanced measurement: Video-specific metrics, attention measurement, and cross-platform attribution.
  • Demand access: Connections to video-specific demand sources and buyers seeking premium video inventory.

SSPs that invest in video capabilities position themselves as essential partners in publisher transformation. Those that remain focused primarily on display advertising risk being left behind as their publisher clients diversify their revenue streams. The FreeWheel data shows that programmatic video is growing significantly faster than non-programmatic, with a 14% year-over-year rise in unique advertisers leveraging automated delivery :cite[cvs]. SSPs that can help publishers access this programmatic demand while maintaining yield on their premium video inventory will capture an outsized share of the growing video market.

Risks and Considerations

A video-first pivot is not without risks. Publishers should consider:

  • Production costs: Video is significantly more expensive to produce than text. Without careful cost management and revenue modeling, video investments can consume resources without generating adequate returns.
  • Talent and skills: Video production requires different skills than text journalism or content marketing. Publishers may need to hire, train, or partner to build these capabilities.
  • Platform dependence: Distributing through YouTube, social platforms, or FAST aggregators creates new platform dependencies that carry their own risks.
  • Audience transition: Existing audiences may not follow publishers into video formats. Building video audiences often requires starting fresh.
  • Competition: The video market is competitive, with established players, well-funded creators, and streaming giants all vying for attention and advertising spend.

These risks are real, but they must be weighed against the certain decline of text-based, search-dependent monetization. The question is not whether to accept risk, but which risks offer the best probability of sustainable success.

Conclusion: The Strategic Imperative

The AI-powered traffic collapse is not a temporary disruption to be weathered. It is a permanent restructuring of how information is discovered and consumed online. Publishers who continue to depend primarily on search-driven traffic to text-based content will see their businesses erode as AI Overviews, chatbots, and zero-click search behavior expand. The 25-89% traffic declines being reported today are harbingers of a future where text content is increasingly commoditized, summarized, and abstracted away from its original sources. Video-first monetization offers a defensible alternative. Video content resists easy summarization, commands premium advertising rates, generates valuable first-party data, and creates contained viewing environments where publishers control the user experience. The CTV market specifically is experiencing sustained double-digit growth, with programmatic capabilities expanding rapidly and advertisers actively shifting budgets from search and social into streaming environments. For publishers, the strategic imperative is clear: build video capabilities now, before the text-based revenue runway runs out entirely. For SSPs and ad tech platforms, the imperative is equally urgent: ensure you have the video-specific capabilities your publishers will need as they transform their businesses. The publishers who act decisively, invest intelligently, and execute effectively will find sustainable paths forward. Those who wait for the crisis to pass will discover there is no passing. Video-first is not merely a monetization strategy. It is a survival strategy.

Red Volcano specializes in publisher discovery and analysis tools for the supply side of ad tech, including Magma Web for web publisher research, mobile app discovery with SDK intelligence, and connected television data platforms. Our technology stack tracking, ads.txt/sellers.json monitoring, and publisher sales outreach services help SSPs, ad networks, and ad tech companies identify, evaluate, and engage the publishers best suited to their business objectives.